Skip to main content

Table 3 Classification performance of the various models in single and multiple regions on both the validation and independent test set

From: A transformer-based multi-task deep learning model for simultaneous infiltrated brain area identification and segmentation of gliomas

  

Validation set

   

Independent test set

   

Number

Model

AUC (95% CI)

ACC

SEN

SPE

AUC (95% CI)

ACC

SEN

SPE

 

VGG16

80.56 (68.09–90.84)

71.11

77.78

69.44

84.08 (78.08–89.24)

75.68

89.19

72.30

 

Resnet50

88.73 (76.55–97.10)

87.78

88.89

87.50

93.22 (88.37–96.90)

89.19

89.19

89.19

 

Efficientb0

90.74 (81.94–97.80)

84.44

83.33

84.72

91.36 (84.77–96.67)

84.86

86.49

84.46

One

COM-Net

92.21 (85.64–97.21)

83.33

88.89

81.94

97.55 (95.14–99.30)

91.89

91.89

91.89

 

MTTU-Net

92.75 (86.13–97.84)

86.67

88.89

86.11

98.50 (96.49–99.85)

93.51

94.59

93.24

 

Ours

94.02 (88.58–98.00)

86.67

88.89

86.11

98.90 (97.46–99.94)

96.76

94.59

97.30

 

 + clinical

characteristics

96.26 (91.93–99.47)

91.11

94.44

90.28

97.24 (94.83–99.21)

95.68

89.19

97.30

 

VGG16

81.25 (66.35–93.81)

80.00

75.00

83.33

77.33 (66.20–86.97)

70.67

63.33

75.56

 

Resnet50

91.15 (80.53–98.47)

85.00

87.50

83.33

81.26 (70.36–91.34)

76.00

73.33

77.78

 

Efficientb0

91.41 (80.91–97.95)

85.00

87.50

83.33

78.89 (67.36–89.08)

73.33

76.67

71.11

Two

COM-Net

89.06 (76.69–97.99)

85.00

87.50

83.33

82.30 (70.99–91.90)

78.67

76.67

80.00

 

MTTU-Net

92.45 (82.34–98.93)

80.00

81.25

79.17

87.56 (78.95–94.48)

78.67

73.33

82.22

 

Ours

91.93 (81.45–98.96)

80.00

75.00

83.33

91.48 (84.27–97.08)

85.33

80.00

88.89

 

 + clinical

characteristics

95.18 (86.89–100)

92.50

87.50

95.83

94.44 (89.02–98.25)

89.33

86.67

91.11

 

VGG16

58.33 (14.29–95.83)

60.00

50.00

75.00

66.67 (25.00–100)

80.00

66.67

100.00

 

Resnet50

100 (100–100)

100

100

100

100 (100–100)

100

100

100

 

Efficientb0

91.67 (66.67–100)

80.00

83.33

75.00

87.50 (55.56–100)

80.00

83.33

75.00

Three

COM-Net

70.83 (22.22–100)

70.00

66.67

75.00

79.17 (41.67–100)

70.00

66.67

75.00

 

MTTU-Net

83.33 (47.62–100)

70.00

66.67

75.00

100 (100–100)

80.00

66.67

100

 

Ours

95.83 (77.78–100)

80.00

66.67

100

100 (100–100)

100

100

100

 

 + clinical

characteristics

100 (100–100)

80.00

66.67

100

100 (100–100)

90.00

83.33

100