Skip to main content

Table 2 Performance evaluation of the models in the development cohort and validation cohort

From: Preoperative CT-based radiomics combined with tumour spread through air spaces can accurately predict early recurrence of stage I lung adenocarcinoma: a multicentre retrospective cohort study

 

AUC (95%CI)

Sensitivity

Specificity

PPV

NPV

Accuracy

Youden Index

Training cohort

 Rad-tumoral

0.785 (0.681–0.890)

0.840

0.705

0.339

0.961

0.726

0.545

 Rad-peritumoral-3u

0.680 (0.568–0.792)

0.920

0.432

0.225

0.968

0.506

0.352

 Rad-peritumoral-6u

0.685 (0.574–0.796)

0.800

0.583

0.256

0.942

0.616

0.383

 Rad-peritumoral-12u

0.688 (0.576–0.800)

0.760

0.583

0.247

0.931

0.610

0.343

 Rad-DeepL-2d

0.692 (0.579–0.805)

0.840

0.590

0.269

0.953

0.628

0.430

 Rad-DeepL-3d

0.629 (0.509–0.750)

0.640

0.633

0.239

0.907

0.634

0.273

 STAS

0.727 (0.654–0.799)

0.920

0.511

0.253

0.973

0.573

0.431

 RAISm

0.847 (0.762–0.932)

0.800

0.871

0.526

0.960

0.860

0.671

Test cohort

 Rad-tumoral

0.727(0.533–0.921)

0.875

0.556

0.226

0.968

0.597

0.431

 Rad-peritumoral-3u

0.780(0.560–1.000)

0.750

0.833

0.400

0.957

0.823

0.583

 Rad-peritumoral-6u

0.745(0.552–0.939)

0.750

0.722

0.286

0.951

0.726

0.472

 Rad-peritumoral-12u

0.829(0.685–0.972)

0.875

0.630

0.259

0.971

0.661

0.505

 Rad-DeepL-2d

0.734(0.590–0.878)

0.875

0.574

0.233

0.969

0.613

0.449

 Rad-DeepL-3d

0.576(0.333–0.819)

0.500

0.778

0.250

0.913

0.742

0.278

 STAS

0.606(0.433–0.780)

0.750

0.463

0.171

0.926

0.500

0.213

 RAISm

0.750(0.531–0.969)

0.875

0.667

0.280

0.973

0.694

0.542

Validation cohort

 Rad-tumoral

0.768(0.625–0.912)

0.585

0.900

0.960

0.346

0.647

0.485

 Rad-peritumoral-3u

0.663(0.509–0.818)

0.439

1.000

1.000

0.303

0.549

0.439

 Rad-peritumoral-6u

0.583(0.406–0.760)

0.366

0.900

0.938

0.257

0.471

0.266

 Rad-peritumoral-12u

0.593(0.374–0.812)

0.659

0.600

0.871

0.300

0.647

0.259

 Rad-DeepL-2d

0.568(0.390–0.746)

0.512

0.800

0.913

0.286

0.569

0.312

 Rad-DeepL-3d

0.522(0.332–0.712)

0.220

1.000

1.000

0.238

0.373

0.220

 STAS

0.713(0.555–0.872)

0.585

0.800

0.923

0.320

0.627

0.385

 RAISm

0.817(0.625–1.000)

0.951

0.700

0.929

0.778

0.902

0.651

  1. AUC Area under the receiver operating characteristics curve, CI Confidence interval, PPV Positive predictive values, NPV Negative predictive values, Rad-tumoral Tumoral radiomics signature, Rad-peritumoral-3u Peritumoral radiomic signature extracted from the 3 voxel units peritumoral area, Rad-peritumoral-6u Peritumoral radiomic signature extracted from the 6 voxel units peritumoral area, Rad-peritumoral-12u Peritumoral radiomic signature extracted from the 12 voxel units peritumoral area, Rad-DeepL-2d Radiomics signature constructed by 2d deep learning features, Rad-DeepL-3d Radiomics signature constructed by 3d deep learning features, STAS Spread through air spaces, RAISm RAdiomcs Integrated with STAS status model