Skip to main content

Table 5 Summary of the studies on radiomics analysis of HCC

From: The application of texture quantification in hepatocellular carcinoma using CT and MRI: a review of perspectives and challenges

Authors

Objectives

Study

Significant features/model

Phase

Summary

Oh et al. [69]

Predict tumor grade and DFS

CECT

SD, MPP and skewness

AP

AP based CCR model correlated well with tumor grade and DFS after resection

S. Song et al. [70]

Differentiate hypervascular lesions

CECT

Histogram, GLCM and GLRLM

AP

AP features characterized hypervascular liver lesions

Mokrane et al. [71]

Verify indeterminate liver nodules

CECT

Radiomic signature using KNN, SVM, and RF

AP and PVP

Machine-learning-identified feature diagnosed HCC in patients with indeterminate liver nodules

Huang et al. [72]

Characterization of HCC based on gene expression

Gd-EOB-DTPA MRI

GLCM, GLRLM and GLSZM-based signature computed using SVM

AP, PVP, DP, and HBP

A radiomic model predicted DPHCC preoperatively

Ma and Peng et al. [56]

Prediction of MVI

CECT

Radiomic signature computed with SVM and LASSO

PVP

CCR model was useful in preoperative and individualized prediction of MVI

Yang et al. [41]

Prediction of MVI

Gd-EOB-DTPA MRI

Radiomic signature computed with LASSO

HBP, T1W and HBP T1 map

HBP T1W and HBP T1 maps radiomic signature were independent predictors of MVI

Zhu et al. [58]

Preoperative prediction of MVI

MRI

Uniformity, CP, CS and LRLGLE in CCR

AP

CCR model predictive of MVI

Zhang et al. [59]

Prediction of ER

Gd-EOB-DTPA MRI

Histogram, GLCM, HGLRE in CCR computed with LASSO

T2W, AP, HBP

CCR had a better predictive ability of ER

Zhou et al. [60]

Prediction of ER

CECT

Histogram and GLCM radiomic signature computed with LASSO

AP, PVP

AP and PVP based CCR was a significant predictor of ER

Zhang et al. [22]

Prediction of ER

MRI

Uniformity, entropy, and skewness

AP

AP features were independent predictors of ER.

Brenet Defour et al. [73]

Prediction of OS

CECT

Skewness

PVP

Skewness associated with OS and useful for selecting best candidates for resection.

Zheng et al. [74]

Prediction of OS and TTR

CECT

GLCM radiomic signature computed with LASSO

AP

Low rad-score correlated with aggressive tumor phenotypes and predictive of postoperative outcome

Song et al. [75]

Prediction of RFS

MRI

Histogram, GRLM, GLCM, GLSZM based signature computed with LASSO

PVP

Preoperative estimation of RFS

Kim et al. [42]

Prediction of survival

CECT

Histogram, GLCM, GLSZM, and 2 shape-based features incorporated into CCR using LASSO

AP

A CCR nomogram performed better in survival prediction

Fu et al. [63]

Treatment and prediction of TTP and OS

CECT

Gabor filter and wavelet transform

PVP

Appropriate selection of HCC’s for TACE plus sorafenib

Kloth et al. [65]

Response assessment after TACE

CECT/pCT

Entropy, mean heterogeneity, uniformity, and skewness

AP/PVP

Significant correlation between texture features and pCT parameters in prediction of response

  1. AP arterial phase, PVP portal venous phase, CCR combined clinical-radiologic/pathologic radiomic model, LRLGLE Long-run low gray-level emphasis, CP Cluster Prominence, CS ClusterShade, HGLRE High gray-level run emphasis, GLN gray-level run-length nonuniformity, GLGCM gray-level gradient co-occurrence matrix, GWTF Gabor wavelet transform texture, OS overall survival, TTP time to progression, TTR time to recurrence, DFS disease free survival, PFS progression free survival, BCLC Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer, ER early recurrence, TACE transarterial chemoembolization, RFS recurrence free survival, DPHCC dual-phenotype hepatocellular carcinoma, pCT perfusion CT, RF random forest, KNN K-nearest neighbor, SVM support vector machine